All stories by Elisabeth Vincentelli on BroadwayStars

Wednesday, November 5, 2025

3 Plays About Jewish Identity That Resist Easy Answers by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The Off Broadway shows “Hannah Senesh,” “Jewish Plot” and “Playing Shylock” take stock of discussions around casting and storytelling.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 08:42AM
Tuesday, November 4, 2025

‘Messy White Gays’ Review: A Satire We’ve Seen Before by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Drew Droege’s newest play Off Broadway is a lot like his others, skewering the entitlement of wealthy, oblivious gay men in Manhattan.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 11:48AM
Monday, November 3, 2025

‘Romy & Michele: The Musical’ Review: Just Following the Script by Elisabeth Vincentelli

This movie adaptation has a couple of laughs, but could have been better served by expanding its reach.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:36AM
Saturday, November 1, 2025

15 Off Broadway Shows to Catch in November by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Tom Hanks returns to New York theater alongside Kelli O’Hara, and Ariana DeBose leads “The Baker’s Wife,” a cult musical.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:18AM
Thursday, October 30, 2025

‘Bat Boy: The Musical’ Review: He’s Just Trying to Fit In by Elisabeth Vincentelli

For its gala, New York City Center revives an antic show about a half-man tabloid sensation, with catchy music and lyrics by the versatile Laurence O’Keefe.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 07:06PM
Tuesday, October 28, 2025

‘Liberation’ Review: A Tony-Worthy Ensemble Plotting Revolution by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Bess Wohl’s play, about a consciousness-raising group in 1970s Ohio, transfers to Broadway where it remains powerfully moving — and funny.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 10:36PM
Friday, October 24, 2025

Tom Morello Brings Rage to an Unexpected Genre: the Musical by Elisabeth Vincentelli

This firebrand guitarist pulled songs from his lesser-known catalog for “Revolution(s),” about family of activists, now playing in Chicago.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:02AM
Wednesday, October 22, 2025

‘Blue Cowboy’ Review: A Surprising Love Rides Into Town by Elisabeth Vincentelli

David Cale’s astonishing one-man show in Brooklyn erects some familiar signposts before swerving into the unexpected.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 12:12PM
Tuesday, October 21, 2025

‘Paranormal Activity’ Wants to Scare You From the Stage by Elisabeth Vincentelli and Evan Jenkins

Like “Stranger Things” and “Harry Potter,” this horror film franchise is branching out with an original story that aims to pull the rug from under theatergoers.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:24AM
Wednesday, October 15, 2025

George Clooney in ‘Good Night, and Good Luck,’ and More Theater to Stream by Elisabeth Vincentelli

This month’s picks include Clooney’s Broadway run as the CBS journalist Edward R. Murrow and an audio play starring Hugh Jackman.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:42AM
Thursday, October 9, 2025

‘Severance’ Star Jen Tullock Works Through Christian Upbringing in New Play by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Jen Tullock’s Off Broadway play, “Nothing Can Take You From the Hand of God,” delves into growing up in a Christian family.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:24AM
Tuesday, September 30, 2025

‘And Then We Were No More’ Review: Not Quite Kafka by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The actor Tim Blake Nelson has penned a dystopian drama set in an unspecified future that puts forth lofty themes. Too bad it’s short on specifics.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 12:36PM
Monday, September 29, 2025

‘Punch’ Review: After a Fatal Blow, an Unlikely Connection by Elisabeth Vincentelli

James Graham’s Broadway play tells the true story of how restorative justice brought together a young man who threw a fatal punch and the parents of the victim.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 09:48PM

For Natalie Palamides, ‘Weer’ and Her Stage Work Are Her Clowning Glory by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Natalie Palamides’s mind-scrambling work oscillates between big laughs and pathos. Her show “Weer” is the first long run at the renovated Cherry Lane Theater.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:31AM
Tuesday, September 16, 2025

In ‘Art,’ James Corden, Bobby Cannavale and Neil Patrick Harris Go to War by Elisabeth Vincentelli

James Corden, Bobby Cannavale and Neil Patrick Harris star in a revival of Yasmina Reza’s comedy about an inscrutable abstract painting.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 10:06PM
Friday, September 12, 2025

Theater to Stream: Mark Rylance in ‘Twelfth Night,’ and More by Elisabeth Vincentelli

This month’s picks include a 1974 adaptation of the Eugene Ionesco play “Rhinoceros,” starring Gene Wilder and Zero Mostel, and a behind-the-scenes look at Disney.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 12:24PM
Wednesday, September 10, 2025

‘Saturday Church’ Puts House Music, Gospel, Sia and ‘Noisy Singers’ Together by Elisabeth Vincentelli and Mohamed Sadek

“Saturday Church” taps into music from several genres, as well as Sia, to tell the story of a teenager struggling with his sexuality and faith.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:12AM
Monday, September 8, 2025

13 Off Broadway Shows to See in September by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Henrik Ibsen’s “The Wild Duck,” an early Celine Song play and John Leguizamo’s new family drama — here’s what’s on New York stages this month.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:32AM
Friday, August 15, 2025

‘Mamma Mia!’ Is Back on Broadway. But Did It Ever Really Leave Us? by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The musical, just like the Abba songs that inspired it, has become an everlasting part of the pop-culture landscape.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:03AM
Thursday, August 7, 2025

Elizabeth McGovern as a Sultry Bombshell? This Isn’t ‘Downton Abbey.’ by Elisabeth Vincentelli

“It’s very liberating to take off that psychological corset,” the actress said of portraying the rambunctious Hollywood star Ava Gardner onstage.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 01:03PM
Monday, August 4, 2025

In Wisconsin, Cheese and Packers Stories Help Northern Sky Theater Thrive by Elisabeth Vincentelli and Jenn Ackerman and Tim Gruber

Northern Sky Theater in Door County programs original musicals steeped in local history, archetypes and customs.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:24AM
Monday, July 21, 2025

‘Joy’ Review: A Rags-to-QVC-Riches Story by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Betsy Wolfe shines as the inventor of the Miracle Mop in a largely dull Off Broadway show.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:06PM
Saturday, July 19, 2025

Taye Diggs Can’t Resist a Good Rom-Com by Elisabeth Vincentelli

“There is the element of love, which can be so serious and so complicated, but when you add the dynamic of humor, it makes it so much more real and exciting and fun to watch.”

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:03AM
Tuesday, July 15, 2025

Theater to Stream: Morgan Freeman in ‘Gospel at Colonus’ and More by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Can’t catch the live revival of this retelling of “Oedipus at Colonus”? Stream a version with Freeman and Robert Earl Jones, or four more stage-related shows.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:24AM
Tuesday, July 8, 2025

‘Heathers: The Musical’ Returns to New York, Fueled by a Devoted Fandom by Elisabeth Vincentelli

An adaptation of the 1980s teen movie with an apocalyptic bent was fine-tuned in London. Now it’s returning to New York.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:06AM
Monday, July 7, 2025

11 Off Broadway Plays to See in July by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Here’s what’s onstage in New York: a new musical about Joy Mangano of Miracle Mop fame, and two plays from the “Oh, Mary!” director Sam Pinkleton.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:36AM
Tuesday, July 1, 2025

In Three Off Broadway Shows, They’re Coming Out and Out and Out by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Several recent productions have featured a range of L.G.B.T.Q. stories, from strained familial relationships to self-discovery via Disney cosplay.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 11:18AM
Wednesday, June 25, 2025

‘Lowcountry’ Review: A Flat-Footed First Date by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Abby Rosebrock’s latest offering for Atlantic Theater Company mines fertile ground, but simmers about with nary a sign of tension, sexual or otherwise.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 09:32PM
Tuesday, June 17, 2025

How ‘Passengers’ Retooled After a Performer’s Injury by Elisabeth Vincentelli

The company presenting the train travel-themed show at the Perelman Performing Arts Center faced a stressful predicament when a performer was suddenly sidelined.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 05:18AM
Friday, June 13, 2025

‘Imaginary Invalid’ and Taylor Mac’s ‘Prosperous Fools’: Fresh Looks at Molière by Elisabeth Vincentelli

Red Bull Theater’s smart “The Imaginary Invalid” and Taylor Mac’s dismaying “Prosperous Fools” attempt to engage with the French writer’s comedy.

SOURCE: The New York Times Subscription at 12:18PM
Sunday, June 8, 2025

All that Chat