All stories by Gary Naylor on BroadwayStars

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

The Two Gentlemen of Verona, RSC, Stratford review - not quite the intended gateway drug to Shakespeare by Gary Naylor

★★★ THE TWO GENTLEMEN OF VERONA, RSC, STRATFORD Youth-oriented version of youthful play Shakespeare trying out lots of ideas that were to bear fruit in the future I have two guilty se…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 04:48PM
Friday, August 1, 2025

Top Hat, Chichester Festival Theatre review - top spectacle but book tails off by Gary Naylor

★★★★ TOP HAT, CHICHESTER FESTIVAL THEATRE Lovely to look at, but don't think too much Glitz and glamour in revived dance show based on Fred and Ginger's movie After 76 years, you�…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 06:12AM
Tuesday, July 29, 2025

Maiden Voyage, Southwark Playhouse review - new musical runs aground by Gary Naylor

★★ MAIDEN VOYAGE, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE All women crew sail around the world, singing, grouching and bonding Pleasant tunes well sung and a good story, but not a good show As the nation b…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:42PM
Monday, July 28, 2025

Brixton Calling, Southwark Playhouse review - life-affirming entertainment, both then and now by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ BRIXTON CALLING, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE The story of two men & one venue is a delight Nostalgic, but the message is bang up to date What a delight it is to see the direct…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:32PM

The Winter's Tale, RSC, Stratford review - problem play proves problematic by Gary Naylor

★★★ THE WINTER'S TALE, RSC, STRATFORD Bleak production that skewers male jealousy Strong women have the last laugh, but the play's bizarre structure overwhelms everything There’s a d…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:32PM
Monday, July 21, 2025

Don't Rock the Boat, The Mill at Sonning review - all aboard for some old-school comedy mishaps by Gary Naylor

★★★★ DON'T ROCK THE BOAT, THE MILL AT SONNING Sound of shared laughter excuses flaws Great fun, if more 20th century than 21st Now 45 years in the past, its dazzling star gone a deca…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:18PM
Thursday, July 17, 2025

Poor Clare, Orange Tree Theatre review - saints cajole us sinners by Gary Naylor

★★★★ POOR CLARE, ORANGE TREE THEATRE Chira Atik's award-winning comedy packs a punch Funny and clever show illuminated by a dazzling debut from Arsema Thomas What am I, a philosophic…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:12PM
Thursday, July 10, 2025

Girl From The North Country, Old Vic review - Dylan's songs fail to lift the mood by Gary Naylor

★★★ GIRL FROM THE NORTH COUNTRY, OLD VIC Conor McPherson's smash hit is looking dated already Fragmented, cliched story rescued by tremendous acting, singing and music Well, I wasn’t…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 07:48AM
Friday, June 27, 2025

Hercules, Theatre Royal Drury Lane review - new Disney stage musical is no 'Lion King' by Gary Naylor

★★★ HERCULES, THEATRE ROYAL Show aimed at a family audience delivers enough, but no more Big West End crowdpleaser lacks punch and poignancy with join-the-dots plotting and cookie-cut…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:18PM
Tuesday, June 24, 2025

Showmanship, Hampstead Theatre review - lip-synced investigation of words, theatricality and performance by Gary Naylor

★★ SHOWMANSHIP, HAMPSTEAD THEATRE Dickie Beau's one-man show is lost in too large a venue  Technically accomplished production with Dickie Beau never settles into a coherent whole I th…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 06:36AM
Sunday, June 15, 2025

North by Northwest, Alexandra Palace review - Hitchcock adaptation fails to fly by Gary Naylor

★ NORTH BY NORTHWEST, ALEXANDRA PALACE Too small a show in too large a venue Emma Rice's storytelling at fault in misconceived production Older readers may recall the cobbled together, ra…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:24PM
Friday, June 13, 2025

Hamlet Hail to the Thief, RSC, Stratford - Radiohead mark the Bard's card by Gary Naylor

★★★★ HAMLET HAIL TO THE THIEF, RSC Music drives the prince to madness in spectacular show An innovative take on a familiar play succeeds far more often than it fails The safe transfe…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:48PM
Thursday, June 12, 2025

The King of Pangea, King's Head Theatre - grief and hope, but no connection, in new musical by Gary Naylor

★★ THE KING OF PANGEA, KING'S HEAD THEATRE - Highly personal American musical fails to land in London Heart and soul proves insufficient in world premiere of therapeutic show There’s a…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:48PM
Thursday, May 29, 2025

This is My Family, Southwark Playhouse - London debut of 2013 Sheffield hit is feeling its age by Gary Naylor

★★★ THIS IS MY FAMILY, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE Play with music engenders a familiar warmth Relatable or stereotyped - that's for you to decide MOR. Twee. Unashamedly crowdpleasing. Are suc…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:02PM
Wednesday, May 28, 2025

The Frogs, Southwark Playhouse review - great songs save updated Aristophanes comedy by Gary Naylor

★★★ THE FROGS, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE Pantomimeish adaptation of classic play Tone never settles, but Sondheim's genius carries the day As a regular theatregoer, you learn pretty quickly …

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 07:32AM
Wednesday, May 7, 2025

The Gang of Three, King's Head Theatre - three old Labour ghosts resurrected to entertain and educate by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ THE GANG OF THREE, KING'S HEAD THEATRE The big beasts banter 50 years ago Beautifully written and equally well acted play resonates down the decades There was a time when the…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:54PM

Conversations After Sex, Park Theatre review - pillow talk proves a snooze by Gary Naylor

★★ CONVERSATIONS AFTER SEX, PARK THEATRE Nudity, but nothing new in UK debut Award-winning Irish play fails to reach a memorable climax In Dublin, a city that has changed more than most …

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:24AM
Monday, April 28, 2025

Much Ado About Nothing, RSC, Stratford - Messina FC scores for new production by Gary Naylor

★★★★ MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING, RSC, STRATFORD Medieval court's mores translates uncomfortably well to modern football Garish and gossipy, this new production packs a punch between the…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:03PM
Thursday, April 17, 2025

Ghosts, Lyric Hammersmith Theatre - turns out, they do fuck you up by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ GHOSTS, LYRIC HAMMERSMITH - Ibsen screams into 2025 in this perfect reimagining Ten years on, Gary Owen and Rachel O'Riordan top their triumphant Iphigenia in Splott A singl…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:18PM
Saturday, April 12, 2025

Midnight Cowboy, Southwark Playhouse - new musical cannot escape the movie's long shadow by Gary Naylor

★ MIDNIGHT COWBOY, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE Ambitious project overwhelmed by challenges  Two misfits misfire in misconceived show It seems a bizarre idea. Take a pivotal film in American cult…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:03PM
Wednesday, April 2, 2025

The Importance of Being Oscar, Jermyn Street Theatre review - Wilde, still burning bright by Gary Naylor

★★★★ THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING OSCAR, JERMYN STREET THEATRE One man play from 1960 given a compelling revival Alastair Whatley honours his subject in a quietly powerful performance It�…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 02:48PM
Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Stiletto, Charing Cross Theatre review - new musical excess by Gary Naylor

★★★★ STILETTO, CHARING CROSS THEATRE Castrato finds comfort by the canals Quirky, operatic show won't please everyone, but will delight many That friend you have who hates musicals…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:42PM
Friday, March 28, 2025

Alfred Hitchcock Presents - The Musical - production based on the old trickster's TV series isn't a screaming success, at least not yet by Gary Naylor

★★★ ALFRED HITCHCOCK PRESENTS - THE MUSICAL, THEATRE ROYAL BATH Ambitious new musical isn't slaying 'em in the aisles  1950s America feels a lot like 2020s America in this portmantea…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 10:54PM
Sunday, March 9, 2025

Edward II, RSC, Swan Theatre, Stratford review - monarchs, murder and mayhem from Marlowe by Gary Naylor

★★★★ EDWARD II, SWAN THEATRE Rapid and racy adaptation draws on its writer's legend Putsch in the palace brings down a king who chose the wrong person to love “Don’t put your c…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:06PM
Wednesday, February 19, 2025

Hamlet, Royal Shakespeare Theatre - Luke Thallon triumphs as the state succumbs to storms by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ HAMLET, ROYAL SHAKESPEARE THEATRE Rupert Goold's staging lends a gnawing, troubling, transatlantic relevance  The iceberg cometh The date, projected behind the stage before …

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:48PM
Thursday, February 13, 2025

Three Sisters, Sam Wanamaker Playhouse review - Chekhov's anatomy lesson on the human condition by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ THREE SISTERS, SAM WANAMAKER PLAYHOUSE Souls dissected in brilliantly conceived and executed production Russia - but also here, there and everywhere Russia.

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:48PM
Wednesday, February 5, 2025

Mrs President, Charing Cross Theatre review - Mary Todd Lincoln on her life alone by Gary Naylor

★ MRS PRESIDENT, CHARING CROSS THEATRE A widow, a photographer but no soul Curious play that fails to mobilise theatre's unique ability to tell a story The phenomenal global success of Si…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 08:42AM
Tuesday, February 4, 2025

Second Best, Riverside Studios review - Asa Butterfield brings the magic by Gary Naylor

★★★ SECOND BEST, RIVERSIDE STUDIOS First-class performance in a second-class play Martin is not Harry Potter in the movies, then might be in real life, but proves to be the boy who sur…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 03:06PM
Sunday, February 2, 2025

Play On!, Lyric Hammersmith - and give me excess of it! by Gary Naylor

★★★★★ PLAY ON!, LYRIC HAMMERSMITH The Bard and The Duke in perfect harmony! Super performances deliver magnificent entertainment If you saw Upstart Crow on television or on stage i…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:54PM
Friday, January 24, 2025

An Interrogation, Hampstead Theatre review - police procedural based on true crime tale fails to ring true by Gary Naylor

★★★ AN INTERROGATION, HAMPSTEAD THEATRE Detective gets her man, but at what cost? Rosie Sheehy and Jamie Ballard shine in Edinburgh Festival import In a dingy room with dilapidated fu…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 09:42PM

Cymbeline, Sam Wanamaker Playhouse review - pagan women fight the good fight by Gary Naylor

★★★ CYMBELINE, SAM WANAMAKER PLAYHOUSE Patriarchy defeated! A new, if not as radical as once it were, take on Shakespeare's cross-dressing call to arms There’s not much point in ha…

SOURCE: theartsdesk.com at 11:42AM